Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
opskrift

From sugar cookies to rugelach: 15 Christmas cookies ranked by tradition and crowd appeal

Anette-Anette Søstrøm Asmussen
 

Anette loves baking, especially bread and cakes. Classic Danish dishes and desserts also take up a lot of her everyday life.

19. November 2026

This roundup covers 15 of the most beloved holiday cookie varieties – everything from the universal crowd-pleasers that belong on every tray to the more specialized classics worth the extra effort. Each entry notes what makes it worth baking and how much skill it takes, so the list serves beginners and experienced bakers equally.

Gingerbread cookies and Danish brown spiced cookies (brunkager) are intentionally left off: both are covered in their own dedicated recipes on this site. Everything here is a different variety.

How we ranked them

Tradition comes first: a cookie with generations of Christmas history ranks above a newer trend, even if both taste great. Crowd appeal comes second: a cookie that pleases kids and people who don’t consider themselves dessert fans ranks above one that appeals to a narrower palate. Ease of making is a tiebreaker in favor of the simpler option. Each entry carries a difficulty rating: Easy (one bowl, no special equipment), Moderate (requires chilling, rolling, or multiple steps), or Challenging (specialty technique or equipment required, plus practice batches expected).

Rank

Cookie

Difficulty

Known for

1

Sugar cookies

Easy-moderate

Cutout shapes, royal icing, universal appeal

2

Snickerdoodles

Easy

Soft, cinnamon-sugar, beginner-friendly

3

Shortbread

Easy

Three ingredients, pure butter flavor

4

Chocolate crinkle cookies

Moderate

Fudgy brownie interior, cracked sugar exterior

5

Mexican wedding cookies

Easy-moderate

Pecan-butter snowballs, make-ahead friendly

6

Spritz cookies

Moderate

Pressed butter cookies, festive shapes

7

Thumbprint cookies

Easy

Jam-filled, no rolling required

8

Molasses crinkle cookies

Easy

Old-fashioned spiced, stays soft for days

9

Peppermint bark cookies

Easy-moderate

Chocolate-peppermint, visual impact

10

Linzer cookies

Moderate-challenging

Almond dough, jam window, looks elaborate

11

Rugelach

Challenging

Cream cheese pastry, wide filling options

12

Pfeffernüsse

Moderate

German spice bite, anise-forward, powdered sugar

13

Pecan tassies

Moderate

Miniature pecan pie cups, Southern classic

14

Almond biscotti

Easy-moderate

Twice-baked, two-week shelf life, great for gifting

15

Cranberry orange drop cookies

Easy

Bright, tart, no chilling or rolling

1. Sugar cookies – the cutout classic

Difficulty: Easy to moderate

No cookie is more tied to Christmas. Cutout shapes – trees, stars, ornaments, snowflakes – are the visual language of the season, and sugar cookies hold those shapes through baking and icing better than any other dough.

They accept royal icing, sanding sugar, and sprinkles cleanly, and the decorating step makes them as much an activity as a recipe.

The dough refrigerates well for up to three days before baking. That means you can make it on Saturday and bake Sunday, or bake plain cookies ahead and ice them the day of a party. The only technical pitfall is overworking the dough: mix until just combined, chill until firm, and roll on a lightly floured surface without pressing hard.

2. Snickerdoodles – soft, cinnamon, and fast

Difficulty: Easy

Soft, puffy, and rolled in cinnamon-sugar before they hit the oven, snickerdoodles are the cookie everyone reaches for even when they cannot name it. Cream of tartar is the defining ingredient: it creates a subtle tang and a chewier texture than a plain sugar cookie.

No chilling, no rolling, no special equipment. Scoop into balls, roll each one in cinnamon-sugar, bake for about 10 minutes. They are among the fastest cookies to go from idea to finished plate, and they stay soft longer than most drop cookies.

3. Shortbread – three ingredients, centuries of tradition

Difficulty: Easy

Butter, sugar, flour – that is the whole recipe. Shortbread bakes low and slow, typically around 325°F (163°C), which draws out moisture without browning and leaves a pale, crumbly cookie with a pure butter flavor. No eggs, no leavening, nothing to curdle or over-rise.

The traditional form is a pressed round scored into wedges and broken after baking. Molds and cutters work too. The only real requirement is good-quality butter; because there is nothing else in the recipe, it shows.

4. Chocolate crinkle cookies – the brownie in cookie form

Difficulty: Moderate

A dark, fudgy chocolate dough is rolled first in granulated sugar, then in powdered sugar, before baking. As the cookie spreads in the oven, the outer layers crack to reveal the dark dough underneath – the visual effect is dramatic and distinctive, and they look professional with almost no decoration work.

The dough needs at least two hours in the refrigerator before rolling; that cold step is what creates the cracks rather than a smooth spread. Flavor-wise, they taste exactly like a brownie, which puts their crowd appeal close to the top of this list.

Read more: Recipes say 5 minutes to caramelize onions. It actually takes 45. Here is the science behind why

5. Mexican wedding cookies – powdered-sugar snowballs

Difficulty: Easy to moderate

Also called snowball cookies or Russian tea cakes, these small pecan-and-butter rounds are coated twice in powdered sugar: once fresh from the oven while still warm, and again when fully cooled. The double coat builds up the dense white exterior that earns them their most common nickname.

The texture is sandy and crumbly – more shortbread than soft cookie – and they melt on contact. They freeze exceptionally well and can be made several weeks before Christmas, which makes them one of the most practical cookies for a large holiday baking schedule.

6. Spritz cookies – pressed into festive shapes

Difficulty: Moderate

Spritz are piped or pressed through a cookie press into trees, wreaths, stars, and rosettes. The dough is a classic Scandinavian butter cookie – simple, rich, and very sensitive to temperature.

Too warm and it spreads on the tray; too cold and the press clogs. That temperature window is the entire skill here.

Once you have it, spritz are among the fastest cookies to produce in volume. Tinted dough or colored sugar makes them look elaborate without adding steps. A cookie press costs roughly $20 and pays for itself the first time you use it.

7. Thumbprint cookies – simple, polished, jam-filled

Difficulty: Easy

A shortbread or sugar cookie dough is rolled into small balls, pressed in the center to create a well, and filled with jam before or after baking. Raspberry and apricot jam are the most traditional fillings at Christmas; a dark chocolate ganache is the crowd-pleasing variation for anyone who finds straight jam too sweet.

No rolling pin, no cutter, no decorating beyond the filling itself. The result looks more finished than the technique suggests, which makes thumbprints one of the best cookies for someone who wants polished results without advanced skills.

8. Molasses crinkle cookies – the spiced old-fashioned

Difficulty: Easy

Deep molasses sweetness combined with ginger, cinnamon, and cloves produces one of the oldest Christmas cookie flavors in American baking. The dough is rolled in granulated sugar before baking, which gives the finished cookie a crackled, glittery surface and a slight crunch against the soft interior.

They stay soft for three to four days longer than most cookies, they are beginner-friendly, and they smell remarkable while baking. If the household already loves gingerbread, molasses cookies are the logical adjacent bake.

Read more: Angelo’s Pizzeria tops Yelp’s Philadelphia cheesesteak ranking as Pat’s and Geno’s finish last

9. Peppermint bark cookies – chocolate and candy cane

Difficulty: Easy to moderate

The classic peppermint bark flavor translated into cookie form: a chocolate cookie base, slightly underbaked so the center stays fudgy, with crushed candy canes pressed in while the cookie is still warm from the oven. Some versions add a drizzle of white chocolate once cooled.

The red-and-white contrast on a dark cookie looks seasonal without any special tools, and the peppermint-chocolate pairing reads as genuinely winter rather than year-round sweet. The main technique note: press the candy cane pieces in firmly right out of the oven, before the surface sets, so they stick.

10. Linzer cookies – the jam-window sandwich

Difficulty: Moderate to challenging

The Linzer cookie draws on the tradition of the Linzer torte: two almond-flavored butter cookies sandwich a layer of preserves, with the top cookie cut to show the filling through a small shape in the center.

Raspberry jam is the most common filling; the red color through a star- or heart-shaped window makes them one of the most visually striking cookies on any holiday tray.

The challenge is rolling the almond dough consistently thin without cracking it and cutting cleanly without distortion. The first batch will teach you the dough’s behavior. By the second, it goes smoothly, and the finished cookies look like they came from a European bakery.

11. Rugelach – cream cheese pastry rolled with filling

Difficulty: Challenging

Rugelach dough is made with cream cheese, which makes it rich, slightly tangy, and forgiving of minor cracks during rolling. The filling options are wide: raspberry or apricot jam, ground walnuts with cinnamon sugar, chocolate chips, dried fruit, or any combination.

Rolling the dough thin, spreading filling to the edge, cutting into triangles, and rolling each piece from the wide end to the tip is a technique that takes a few batches to get smooth.

The first batch will look imperfect and taste excellent. Plan two practice rounds before making these for a cookie exchange. The finished crescents stay fresh at room temperature for about four days or refrigerated for up to two weeks.

12. Pfeffernüsse – German spice bites in powdered sugar

Difficulty: Moderate

Pfeffernüsse are small, dense spice cookies from German Christmas baking, rolled in powdered sugar once cooled. The flavor combines anise, cinnamon, cloves, and cardamom with a small amount of black pepper, which adds a gentle warmth that rounds out the sweetness without registering as heat.

Read more: Why everything sticks to stainless steel pans, and the one preheating trick that fixes it

They are sized to about one inch (2.5 cm) across – truly bite-size – which makes them ideal for a tasting plate.

The anise flavor is the polarizing element: some people love it and some do not. For anyone who grew up eating anise-spiced baking, pfeffernüsse are the definitive holiday cookie and nothing else comes close.

13. Pecan tassies – miniature pecan pie cups

Difficulty: Moderate

Pecan tassies are miniature pecan pies baked in a cream cheese pastry shell pressed into mini muffin tins. Because the dough is pressed rather than rolled, it is significantly less technically demanding than standard pie crust. The filling is a straightforward mixture of eggs, brown sugar, butter, vanilla, and chopped pecans.

Each finished tassie is one or two bites and delivers the full flavor of pecan pie on a cookie tray. They hold well at room temperature for three to four days and are a standard of Southern holiday baking.

Because they are self-contained – no powdered sugar to dust off, no frosting to smear – they travel well to parties and potlucks.

14. Almond biscotti – twice-baked, two weeks shelf life

Difficulty: Easy to moderate

Biscotti are baked in two stages: first as a whole log until set, then sliced and returned to the oven to dry out completely. The double bake removes most of the moisture, producing the characteristic crunch and extending shelf life to two to three weeks in an airtight container.

The classic holiday version uses whole almonds and vanilla. A single end dipped in dark chocolate adds richness without complicating the method. Because they keep so well, almond biscotti are one of the best cookies to make ahead and package as gifts. Stack them in a tin or wrap in cellophane – they hold at room temperature for two to three weeks and do not crumble in transit.

15. Cranberry orange drop cookies – bright, tart, no chilling required

Difficulty: Easy

A drop cookie built on fresh or dried cranberries and orange zest, cranberry orange cookies are the lightest entry on this list. The tartness of the cranberry and the brightness of the orange zest cut through the sweetness of the base dough, which makes them a natural contrast on a tray dominated by chocolate and spiced varieties.

No chilling, no rolling, no special equipment. The dough goes straight from the bowl to the baking sheet by the spoonful. Fresh cranberries give the most vivid flavor; dried cranberries work equally well and need no preparation. Finished cookies keep at room temperature for about four days.