Every Philly cheesesteak fan has a favorite, but this ranking skips the opinions and goes straight to the numbers. All twelve spots below are ranked by their Yelp star rating, pulled from the platform’s Philadelphia cheesesteak listings in November 2026. Where two restaurants share the same star rating, the one with more reviews takes the higher slot.
The result turns the conventional wisdom upside down. Pat’s King of Steaks and Geno’s Steaks – the two 24-hour stands that face each other on the same corner of Passyunk Avenue and claim to have invented the cheesesteak – land at the bottom of the list. The diners who actually rate them have voted clearly: the best cheesesteaks in Philadelphia are found elsewhere.
How we ranked them
Ratings and review counts are from Yelp’s Philadelphia cheesesteak category, updated November 2026. All 12 spots listed here are confirmed open. Where two restaurants share the same star rating, the one with the larger review count ranks higher, since more reviews produce a more reliable average.
Rank | Restaurant | Yelp stars | Reviews | Neighborhood |
|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Angelo’s Pizzeria | 4.5 | 1,437 | Bella Vista |
2 | John’s Roast Pork | 4.4 | 2,016 | South Philly |
3 | Uncle Gus’ Steaks | 4.4 | 211 | Center City |
4 | Cleavers | 4.2 | 1,800 | Center City West |
5 | Dalessandro’s Steaks & Hoagies | 4.1 | 3,689 | Roxborough |
6 | Sonny’s Famous Steaks | 4.0 | 2,099 | Old City |
7 | Max’s Steaks | 4.0 | 929 | Germantown |
8 | Tony and Nick’s Steaks | 3.9 | 2,179 | South Philly |
9 | Steve’s Prince of Steaks | 3.9 | 660 | Northeast Philly |
10 | Jim’s South St | 3.7 | 3,104 | South Street |
11 | Pat’s King of Steaks | 3.2 | 4,895+ | Passyunk Square |
12 | Geno’s Steaks | 2.6 | 3,843 | Passyunk Square |
1. Angelo’s Pizzeria – Bella Vista
4.5 stars, 1,437 Yelp reviews (October 2026)
Angelo’s sits on 9th Street in the heart of South Philly’s Italian Market corridor. It is primarily a pizza shop, but diners rank its cheesesteak at the top of the city. The sandwich is a footlong, built on a house-made seeded hoagie roll with thinly sliced ribeye, Cooper Sharp cheese, and fried onions.
The house-made roll is the detail that sets Angelo’s apart. Almost every other cheesesteak shop in Philadelphia uses off-the-shelf Amoroso rolls. Making the bread in-house gives the crust a snap and a slight tang that changes the whole sandwich.
The shop is at 736 S 9th St and operates Wednesday through Saturday, 11am to 7pm. It is closed Monday and Tuesday, so plan around those days.
2. John’s Roast Pork – South Philly
4.4 stars, 2,016 Yelp reviews (October 2026)
Despite the name, John’s draws as many diners for its cheesesteak as for the roast pork sandwich. Owner John Bucci won a James Beard Award, and the shop later won a Truff-sponsored best cheesesteak competition in Philadelphia, beating out Dalessandro’s, Donkey’s Place, Jay’s Joint, and Jim’s, as reported by WHYY.
The cheesesteak is made in small batches – around 10 to 12 at a time – and comes on a sesame roll with American cheese and grilled onions. John’s is at 14 E Snyder Ave and tends to sell out before early afternoon. Getting there before noon is the safest approach.
3. Uncle Gus’ Steaks – Reading Terminal Market
4.4 stars, 211 Yelp reviews (November 2026)
Uncle Gus’ operates inside Reading Terminal Market at 1136 Arch St in Center City. The lower review count compared to standalone shops reflects the market setting, not the quality: 4.4 stars on 211 reviews puts it level with John’s Roast Pork.
Read more: Why everything sticks to stainless steel pans, and the one preheating trick that fixes it
The cheesesteak is a 10-inch sandwich made with thinly sliced ribeye and Cooper Sharp cheese on a seeded roll from Angelo’s Baking Company. The sandwich costs around $19. Reading Terminal Market hours apply, so check ahead before making the trip.
4. Cleavers – Center City West
4.2 stars, 1,800 Yelp reviews (November 2026)
Cleavers at 108 S 18th St has built a strong following in the Rittenhouse Square neighborhood. The focus is on fresh ribeye, and reviewers consistently point to the quality of the meat and its seasoning. The signature option is the Effin Hot Cheesesteak, a spiced-up version with heat worked into every bite, alongside the classic and a chicken cheesesteak.
A 4.2-star average across 1,800 reviews makes Cleavers the highest-rated cheesesteak shop in Center City proper.
5. Dalessandro’s Steaks & Hoagies – Roxborough
4.1 stars, 3,689 Yelp reviews (November 2026)
Dalessandro’s is at 600 Wendover St in Roxborough, a Northwest Philadelphia neighborhood well off the visitor trail. That distance from the tourist circuit is part of the signal in the reviews: 3,689 Yelp ratings is the highest review count of any restaurant in this list with a 4-star-plus score, and the overwhelming majority are from diners who made the trip specifically for the sandwich.
The standard order is chopped ribeye with sautéed onions. By review volume, it is the most battle-tested of the top-rated options.
6. Sonny’s Famous Steaks – Old City
4.0 stars, 2,099 Yelp reviews (November 2026)
Sonny’s at 228 Market St in Old City uses fresh-sliced domestic ribeye on Amoroso Italian long rolls. The Old City location puts it a short walk from the Liberty Bell and Independence Hall, which keeps a steady flow of visitors through the door.
Read more: Why your scrambled eggs turn rubbery, and the two fixes that actually work
The 4.0-star average across more than 2,000 reviews reflects a consistent operation. For visitors staying near the historic district, Sonny’s is the highest-rated cheesesteak option in the area.
7. Max’s Steaks – Germantown
4.0 stars, 929 Yelp reviews (November 2026)
Max’s Steaks at 3653 Germantown Ave serves the northern neighborhoods of Philadelphia with a traditional-style cheesesteak and has built a loyal following among Germantown and North Philadelphia residents who have no reason to trek to South Philly or Center City.
For anyone spending time in the northern neighborhoods, Max’s is the standout choice on the data.
8. Tony and Nick’s Steaks – South Philly
3.9 stars, 2,179 Yelp reviews (October 2026)
Tony and Nick’s, at 39 E Oregon Ave in South Philly, is the former Tony Luke’s – the original location rebranded under the ownership of Tony Luke Sr and son Nicky Luke. The shop built its following on three sandwiches: the cheesesteak, the roast pork, and the chicken cutlet Italian-style.
With more than 2,100 reviews at 3.9 stars, it is one of the most-reviewed cheesesteak spots in South Philly outside the Pat’s-and-Geno’s intersection.
9. Steve’s Prince of Steaks – Northeast Philly
3.9 stars, 660 Yelp reviews (November 2026)
Steve’s Prince of Steaks at 7200 Bustleton Ave is the top-rated cheesesteak shop in Northeast Philadelphia. The shop occupies the same role in its neighborhood that Dalessandro’s holds in Roxborough: a neighborhood institution with a devoted local following, a long way from the tourist circuit.
Read more: Tartiflette: the French alpine potato and cheese bake for cold nights
The 3.9-star average on 660 reviews is consistent with Steve’s reputation as the best cheesesteak destination in the northeast quadrant of the city.
10. Jim’s South St – South Street
3.7 stars, 3,104 Yelp reviews (October 2026)
Jim’s South St at 400 S St is the most-reviewed cheesesteak shop in this list. More than 3,100 Yelp reviews reflect decades of traffic along one of Philadelphia’s most-visited blocks.
Hours are 10:30am to 11pm Monday through Thursday. The long line that typically forms outside is the most reliable indicator that service is running.
11. Pat’s King of Steaks – Passyunk Square
3.2 stars, 4,895+ Yelp reviews (November 2026)
Pat’s King of Steaks at 1237 E Passyunk Ave is open 24 hours. With close to 4,900 Yelp reviews, it is among the most-reviewed spots in this list – but as a group, those reviewers rate it at 3.2 stars.
The ordering system is part of the experience: state your cheese choice (Whiz, American, or provolone), then whether you want onions (say “wit” for onions or “witout” for none). Pat’s sits directly across from Geno’s on the Passyunk-9th Street intersection and is open around the clock every day of the year.
12. Geno’s Steaks – Passyunk Square
2.6 stars, 3,843 Yelp reviews (November 2026)
Geno’s, at 1219 S 9th St, is the other half of Philadelphia’s most-photographed food rivalry. The shop faces Pat’s from across the same intersection and is also open 24 hours.
The 2.6-star Yelp rating across 3,843 reviews puts Geno’s at the bottom of this data-driven list, well below Pat’s 3.2. By any measure of public reviews, the city’s highest-rated cheesesteak is not on this corner – but for anyone visiting both stands on the same trip, the counter windows at 1219 S 9th St are open at any hour.