This list covers Manhattan and Brooklyn steakhouses ranked by Yelp star rating as of November 2026, with review count as the tiebreaker when scores tie. All 15 restaurants are confirmed open. The goal is a shortlist any visitor or local can use when booking a special meal.
How we ranked them
Yelp star ratings are the primary ranking signal. When two restaurants share the same score, the one with more Yelp reviews ranks higher: a 4.2 from 3,700 diners carries more statistical weight than a 4.2 from 500. Scores were cross-referenced with Google Maps ratings where available. Everything reflects data as of November 2026. Restaurant review scores shift over time; treat these as a solid current snapshot, not a permanent verdict.
At a glance
Rank | Restaurant | Neighborhood | Yelp stars | Yelp reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Bourbon Steak | Midtown West | 4.7 | 327 |
2 | 4 Charles Prime Rib | West Village | 4.6 | 617 |
3 | Vinyl Steakhouse | Flatiron | 4.6 | 265 |
4 | La Grande Boucherie | Midtown | 4.5 | 4,631 |
5 | Club A Steakhouse | Midtown East | 4.5 | 3,644 |
6 | Cote Korean Steakhouse | Flatiron | 4.3 | 2,087 |
7 | Del Frisco’s Double Eagle | Midtown | 4.2 | 3,738 |
8 | Keens Steakhouse | Midtown West | 4.2 | 3,634 |
9 | Gallaghers Steakhouse | Theater District | 4.2 | 2,297 |
10 | Benjamin Steakhouse | Midtown East | 4.2 | 1,611 |
11 | Bowery Meat Company | East Village | 4.1 | 706 |
12 | Peter Luger | Williamsburg, Brooklyn | 4.0 | 7,511 |
13 | Strip House | Greenwich Village | 4.0 | 1,187 |
14 | Wolfgang’s Steakhouse | Murray Hill | 3.9 | 1,239 |
15 | Sparks Steak House | Midtown East | 3.7 | 1,204 |
1. Bourbon Steak — Midtown West
Chef Michael Mina’s modern American steakhouse sits inside the JW Marriott Essex House at 160 Central Park South. It goes well beyond the standard chophouse playbook, pairing USDA Prime and Wagyu beef cuts with an ambitious seafood program and an award-winning wine list. The polished Central Park setting makes it one of the most requested tables in the city for a business dinner or celebration.
Yelp: 4.7 stars, 327 reviews (November 2026).
2. 4 Charles Prime Rib — West Village
The tiny dining room at 4 Charles St in the West Village specializes in exactly what the name says: classic prime rib, in an intimate setting. Reviewers describe the atmosphere as romantic and the experience as consistently excellent. With 617 reviews at 4.6 stars, it has built one of the strongest per-review reputations in the city despite its small footprint.
Yelp: 4.6 stars, 617 reviews (November 2026).
3. Vinyl Steakhouse — Flatiron
Vinyl Steakhouse at 35 W 19th St is the kind of find that earns word-of-mouth devotion fast. Reviewers describe it as “Best steakhouse in NYC by far” and point to its more casual atmosphere and comparatively accessible prices as reasons it punches above better-known names. The sirloin and the creative small plates are the things to order. At 4.6 stars and 265 reviews, it ties 4 Charles Prime Rib on score but trails it on review volume, landing Vinyl at third.
Yelp: 4.6 stars, 265 reviews (November 2026).
4. La Grande Boucherie — Midtown
La Grande Boucherie at 145 W 53rd St blends a French brasserie aesthetic with the ambitions of a serious American steakhouse. The ribeye and porterhouse draw the most praise, and the dining room is dramatic enough to serve as a backdrop for a formal occasion. With over 4,600 reviews at 4.5 stars, it has the volume and score to anchor this tier of the list.
Read more: Individual lemon mousse cakes with a biscuit base: the dinner party dessert you make ahead
Yelp: 4.5 stars, 4,631 reviews (November 2026).
5. Club A Steakhouse — Midtown East
Club A at 240 E 58th St has accumulated 3,644 reviews at 4.5 stars, a combination that tells you this is not a one-visit curiosity. Reviewers call it one of the best steakhouses in the city despite it not always making the biggest media lists. The dry-aged ribeye and the seafood tower are the signature moves. The atmosphere is classy and upscale, good for groups.
Yelp: 4.5 stars, 3,644 reviews (November 2026).
6. Cote Korean Steakhouse — Flatiron
Cote at 16 W 22nd St is a Michelin-starred Korean BBQ concept that takes the American chophouse ritual — tableside cooking, dry-aged beef, shared cuts — and runs it through a Korean lens. The Butcher’s Feast, a rotating selection of four cuts grilled at the table with banchan sides, is the flagship order. It is one of the most distinctive experiences on this list.
Yelp: 4.3 stars, 2,087 reviews (November 2026).
7. Del Frisco’s Double Eagle — Midtown
Del Frisco’s Double Eagle at 1221 Avenue of the Americas is the kind of grand Midtown steakhouse that handles large parties without the experience sliding. The USDA Prime bone-in ribeye is the centerpiece, and the wine list has consistently won awards. With 3,738 Yelp reviews at 4.2 stars, it is one of the most-reviewed steakhouses in this tier.
Yelp: 4.2 stars, 3,738 reviews (October 2026).
8. Keens Steakhouse — Midtown West
Keens at 72 W 36th St is one of the most recognizable names in New York dining, and its Yelp record — 3,634 reviews at 4.2 stars — shows that the reputation is still being earned on the plate. The legendary mutton chop is the dish to order if you’ve never been. The dining room, with its low ceilings and antique clay pipe collection overhead, looks like nothing else in the city.
Read more: Denmark’s iconic cowboy toast gets the smashburger treatment, and it is better than ever
Yelp: 4.2 stars, 3,634 reviews (November 2026).
9. Gallaghers Steakhouse — Theater District
Gallaghers at 228 W 52nd St announces itself with a dry-aging locker visible through the front window, full of beef on display for the street. The Theater District location makes it a natural pre-show choice, and the filet mignon and prime rib are both described by reviewers as standout cuts. Five-star service with an old-school classic atmosphere, as multiple reviewers put it.
Yelp: 4.2 stars, 2,297 reviews (November 2026).
10. Benjamin Steakhouse — Midtown East
Benjamin at 52 E 41st St has a soaring, grand dining room that sets up the expectation of a serious meal, and the food delivers on it. The signature ribeye and the bacon-wrapped filet are the two dishes most referenced in reviews. With 1,611 Yelp reviews at 4.2 stars, it rounds out the 4.2-star tier with a consistent track record.
Yelp: 4.2 stars, 1,611 reviews (September 2026).
11. Bowery Meat Company — East Village
Bowery Meat Company at 9 E 1st St is a modern steakhouse that earns points for a menu that goes beyond standard chophouse territory. The bone-in ribeye is the main event, but the duck lasagna has a following among regulars, and the wine program suits a creative East Village crowd. With 706 reviews at 4.1 stars, it is the smallest operation on this list by review volume.
Yelp: 4.1 stars, 706 reviews (November 2026).
Read more: Boeuf bourguignon at home: the French braised beef that tastes like a Parisian bistro
12. Peter Luger — Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Peter Luger at 178 Broadway in Brooklyn has 7,511 Yelp reviews at 4.0 stars — the most-reviewed steakhouse on this list by a significant margin. The dry-aged porterhouse for two is one of the most iconic dishes in the country. The room is utilitarian, the service is blunt, and the restaurant is cash-only: none of that has stopped the decades-long line for tables.
Yelp: 4.0 stars, 7,511 reviews (November 2026).
13. Strip House — Greenwich Village
Strip House at 13 E 12th St makes an impression before the food arrives: the dining room runs in deep red with the kind of mood lighting that makes a Wagyu ribeye look even better on the plate. The dry-aged NY strip is the flagship cut, and the truffle creamed spinach is one of the more cited side dishes in the city. With 1,187 Yelp reviews at 4.0 stars, it holds its own in the downtown tier.
Yelp: 4.0 stars, 1,187 reviews (November 2026).
14. Wolfgang’s Steakhouse — Murray Hill
Wolfgang’s at 4 Park Ave in Murray Hill is built around a single anchor: the USDA Prime dry-aged porterhouse. The Murray Hill location has 1,239 Yelp reviews at 3.9 stars. The lobster mac and cheese is a popular accompaniment to the main event, and the dining room runs classic-formal in style. It is a solid choice when the other options on this list are fully booked.
Yelp: 3.9 stars, 1,239 reviews (November 2026).
15. Sparks Steak House — Midtown East
Sparks at 210 E 46th St is a classic Midtown chophouse with a well-known address and a menu built around USDA Prime sirloin and lamb chops. The 1,204 Yelp reviews at 3.7 stars make it the lowest-rated restaurant on this list, but it remains a fixture for Midtown business diners and visitors looking for a traditional New York steak experience. Walk-ins can often find a seat at the bar.
Yelp: 3.7 stars, 1,204 reviews (November 2026).