Salmon became the default fish because it is sold everywhere, not because it is the best thing in the case. It is also one of the priciest fillets you can buy.
These seven cost less, cook just as fast, and bring more character to the plate. The USDA cooks fish to 145°F (63°C), the point where the flesh turns opaque and flakes with gentle pressure, and every one of these gets there in minutes.
1. Mackerel
Rich, oily, and loaded with the same good fats people buy salmon for, at a fraction of the price. The strong flavor stands up to bold seasoning.
Grill or broil it skin-side up until the skin blisters. A squeeze of lemon cuts right through the richness.
2. Sardines
Fresh sardines are cheap, fast, and full of flavor; tinned ones are a pantry hero. Either way you are getting a lot of taste for very little money.
Read more: How onions trigger your tears, and the fixes that actually work
Grill fresh ones in minutes, or pile the tinned ones on toast with a little vinegar and chili.
3. Pollock
This is the mild white fish hiding inside most fish sticks and fast-food sandwiches. Bought as fillets it is a bargain, and it fries up sweet and flaky.
Batter and fry it, or bake it with butter and herbs. It takes on whatever flavor you give it.
4. Whiting
A soft, delicate white fish that rarely gets a second look at the counter. It is one of the cheapest fresh fish around and cooks in a flash.
Read more: Baking soda browns your baked goods; baking powder doesn’t, food scientists explain the chemistry
Dust it in seasoned flour and pan-fry it. It is too tender to fuss with, which is the whole appeal.
5. Trout
Freshwater trout gives you much of what people love about salmon, delicate pink flesh and a clean flavor, usually for less. It is often farmed responsibly and sold whole.
Roast it whole with lemon and herbs in the cavity, or pan-fry the fillets skin-on until crisp.
6. Herring
Cheap, sustainable, and deeply flavorful. Fresh herring is wonderful grilled, and pickled or soused herring turns a few cents of fish into something you actually crave.
Read more: The classic French onion soup that actually tastes like the restaurant version, made at home
Grill fresh fillets fast and hot, or buy them cured and serve cold with rye and onions.
7. Hake
A firm, meaty white fish that holds together better than cod and usually costs less. It is a favorite across southern Europe for good reason.
Roast thick fillets or add chunks to a tomato-based stew where they stay in one piece.
How to cook cheap fish well
- Do not overcook it. Fish is done at 145°F (63°C), the moment it turns opaque and flakes. A minute too long is what makes people think they dislike fish.
- Dry the surface first. Pat fillets dry before they hit the pan and the skin crisps instead of steaming.
- Cook oily fish hot, white fish gentle. Mackerel and herring love a blazing grill; whiting and hake want a softer touch.
- Buy whole when it is cheaper. A whole fish keeps the flesh moist, and the bones make a quick stock.