Store-bought sun-dried tomatoes can be leathery, one-dimensional, and aggressively salty. The homemade semi-dried version is something else entirely: slow-roasted at low heat until the tomatoes shrivel and concentrate, but still holding a soft, juicy center. The flavor is intense and rich in a way a store jar simply cannot match.
The technique is almost embarrassingly easy. You quarter cherry tomatoes, spread them on a baking sheet, add coarse salt and a few fresh herb stems, and slide them into a 212°F (100°C) oven for about four hours. While you go about your day, the oven does the work quietly.
Why low and slow is the whole trick
The key is patience and temperature. At 212°F (100°C), the moisture in the tomatoes evaporates gradually rather than cooking off fast, which concentrates the natural sweetness and acidity without turning the tomatoes dry and hard. What you get is a soft, slightly chewy texture with a flavor that hits much harder than fresh tomatoes.
High heat roasts a tomato. Low heat transforms it.
How to make them
Quarter your cherry tomatoes and spread them out on a baking sheet in a single layer, cut side up. They should not be touching or piled up – even spacing means even drying.
Read more: How to make a classic tiramisu that sets perfectly every time, with the creamiest mascarpone layer
Scatter a generous tablespoon or two of coarse salt over the tomatoes. The salt draws out moisture and deepens the flavor. Lay a few stems of fresh rosemary and thyme across the top.
Slide the pan into an oven preheated to 212°F (100°C) and leave them for approximately four hours. When they are ready, the tomatoes will have shriveled noticeably but will still have a soft center when you press one gently. They should not be dry all the way through.
Let them cool completely on the pan before moving on to storage.
Read more: Why your homemade pancakes are flat, and the simple technique that fixes it
Storing them in olive oil
Once the tomatoes are cool, pack them into a sterilized glass jar. Pour over enough good-quality virgin olive oil to submerge them completely – every tomato should be under the surface of the oil. Seal the jar and store it in the refrigerator.
Kept fully submerged and refrigerated, the tomatoes will last 2 to 3 weeks. Always use a clean spoon to lift tomatoes out, and top up the oil if the level drops and tomatoes become exposed.
What to do with them
The uses are almost endless. Semi-dried tomatoes are excellent in pasta, on pizza, in salads, on bruschetta, and on a charcuterie board. Stir them into a tapenade or pesto, or layer them into a sandwich where you want a hit of concentrated tomato flavor.
Read more: The Dagmar: Denmark’s laminated pastry cake that makes croissant lovers weak at the knees
The oil they sit in is just as valuable. After a few days in the jar it absorbs the aroma of the herbs and the tomatoes themselves. Use it in dressings, drizzle it over cooked pasta, or add it to a marinade. It is too good to discard.
Herb variations worth trying
Rosemary and thyme are the classic combination, giving a Mediterranean, slightly resinous depth. Oregano works well for a more Italian-leaning flavor. Fresh basil is delicate and best added after baking, directly into the jar. A clove or two of garlic tucked in among the tomatoes on the pan adds a savory, mellow note.
One batch makes enough to fill a medium jar and lasts long enough to actually use – try a few herb combinations over different batches to find the version you reach for most.