This is one of those recipes that sounds simple, maybe even underwhelming, until you actually make it. Whole mushrooms and cherry tomatoes slow-roast together at 250°F for two to three hours, concentrating their flavor until they taste rich and almost braised. Then you pile them over fresh arugula, crumble feta on top, and drizzle the warm, herb-scented pan juices straight over everything.
That last part is the trick. The pan juices do the work of a vinaigrette, so there is no separate dressing to make. It lands warm on the cold greens and wilts them just enough to pull the whole plate together.
Serve it as a light lunch or alongside grilled meat or fish. It serves four.
Why this recipe works
The long, low roast is everything here. At 250°F, the moisture in the mushrooms and tomatoes evaporates slowly rather than steaming out in a rush, which is what happens at high heat. What you get is a deeply savory, concentrated flavor you simply cannot achieve in 20 minutes at 400°F.
Butter melted into each mushroom cap as it roasts adds richness and joins the olive oil to form the pan juices. Fresh rosemary perfumes the whole thing. By the time it comes out of the oven, the cherry tomatoes practically fall off the vine on their own, and the mushrooms are tender all the way through with lightly caramelized edges.
Ingredients
- 6 large mushrooms, stems removed
- 6 teaspoons butter (1 teaspoon per mushroom)
- A drizzle of olive oil
- A generous amount of fresh rosemary
- 1 pound (500 g) cherry tomatoes on the vine
- All-purpose seasoning or seasoning salt, to taste
- 2.6 oz (75 g) arugula
- 1 generous handful of crumbled feta cheese
- Fresh rosemary, finely chopped, for garnish
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 250°F (120°C on the fan/convection setting).
- Remove the stems from the mushrooms and place the caps gill-side up on a rimmed baking sheet. Nestle the cherry tomatoes on the vine alongside them.
- Drizzle olive oil over everything. Drop 1 teaspoon of butter into each mushroom cap.
- Season with all-purpose seasoning and lay fresh rosemary sprigs over the top.
- Roast for 2 to 3 hours, until the mushrooms are deeply tender and the tomatoes are soft and collapsing. The tomatoes are ready when they slide off the vine with no resistance.
- Spread the arugula across a serving plate or shallow bowl.
- Arrange the roasted mushrooms and tomatoes over the arugula. Pour every drop of the warm pan juices over the greens, that is your dressing.
- Crumble feta generously over the top and finish with a little freshly chopped rosemary. Serve immediately.
Tips and variations
Don’t rush the oven time. Two hours is the minimum; three hours gives you even more concentrated flavor. Check at the two-hour mark and go longer if the mushrooms still feel firm in the center.
On the seasoning: Aromat, the savory all-purpose seasoning powder common across Scandinavia and Europe, is called for in the original recipe. A good all-purpose seasoning or seasoning salt works just as well. Flaky sea salt and a little garlic powder is another clean option.
On the mushrooms: Use large cremini or portobello caps if you want something meatier. Regular white button mushrooms work fine but go a little smaller and roast closer to two hours.
Read more: Homemade rhubarb jam with vanilla: 20 minutes, four ingredients, better than any jar
Make it a main: Add a soft-boiled egg or a few slices of prosciutto draped over the top, and this moves comfortably from side dish to a full lunch plate.
Storage: The roasted mushrooms and tomatoes keep well in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to three days. Reheat them gently, then assemble the salad fresh with new arugula and feta when you’re ready to eat.