Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
opskrift

Are These the Most Overpriced Italian Chains in America?

MieMie Møller Bie

Mie Møller Bie is a Danish food and lifestyle enthusiast who explores both timeless comfort dishes and innovative new recipes, inspired by family life with three children and a food-loving husband.

3. October 2025

Italian restaurant chains were once synonymous with affordable family meals. But rising prices, shrinking portions, and inconsistent quality have diners speaking out.

Here are 12 chains that many reviewers on TripAdvisor, Yelp and other channels say no longer deliver value for money.


Mellow Mushroom

Mellow Mushroom
Google Maps

Known for quirky vibes, Mellow Mushroom now shocks customers with prices. A 16-inch specialty pie can hit $29, while mediums cost nearly the same, leading some to call it “shrinkflation 101.”


Papa Gino’s

Gino's Pizzaria
Google Maps

This New England favorite faces backlash for steadily rising prices. Complaints focus on smaller portions, fewer toppings, and food that no longer justifies the bill.


Bravo! Italian Kitchen

Bravo! Italian Kitchen
Google Maps

Bravo! is called “fake fine dining” by some reviewers on Tripadvisor. Complaints include $3 surcharges for sauces and high prices for entrées described as bland or forgettable.


Buca di Beppo

Buca De Beppo
Sindii Da Silva/Google Maps

After financial troubles, Buca raised prices without improving quality, according to reviews. Diners slam $30 pizzas and describe the food as “overpriced dumpster trash.”

Romano’s Macaroni Grill

Romano's Macaroni Grill
Google Maps

Diners complain of $17 Caesar salads and entrées priced like upscale restaurants, but with “mediocre food and small servings.” Service quality is another recurring frustration.


Sbarro

Sbarro
Làs Vegas/Google Maps

A mall staple turned overpriced pit stop. Pizza slices now push $6–$7 in some locations, but customers say they lack freshness and flavor compared to local shops.


Marco’s Pizza

Marco's pizza
Google Maps

Once known for value, Marco’s is now blasted for $50 orders that include stale dough and skimpy toppings. Many diners say it costs “almost double” competitors for less quality.


Bertucci’s

Betuccini's
Google Maps

With only a handful of locations left, Bertucci’s faces criticism for overpriced dips and tiny portions. One reviewer summed it up: “Olive Garden is bad, but Bertucci’s is its basement cousin.”


Olive Garden

Olive garden
Google Maps

Once famous for endless breadsticks, Olive Garden now frustrates diners with rising costs. Reviews cite “overpriced and poorly cooked” meals, often reaching $40 per person for what many call cafeteria-level food.


Papa Murphy’s

Papa Murphys
Google Maps

Often cited as one of the more expensive pizza chains in the U.S., partly because it’s a “take-n-bake” model, where you pick up the pizza and bake it at home. Eat This Not That calls Papa Murphy’s “very overpriced. One quoted customer said:

“Yesterday I ordered a medium cowboy, a medium garlic chicken, and a monkey bread … With a $4 tip it came to $50! … It’s certainly not a ‘cheap’ option anymore.”


Maggiano’s Little Italy

Little Italy
Google Maps

Known for family-style Italian, Maggiano’s faces backlash for “watered-down sauces” and entrée prices creeping toward high-end dining.

Customers say the cozy atmosphere can’t hide shrinking portions. Some on Yelp also complain about cancellations and rude staff.


California Pizza Kitchen (CPK)

California Pizza
Google Maps

Once trendy for fusion pizzas, CPK is now faulted for $20+ pies and “hipster pricing” without standout flavor. Many diners suggest skipping it for a local slice.